4 The Foodie California

Seafood City on City Island, NY

City Island, located in the Bronx, NY, is known for a handful of things! Besides scenes from one of my favorite movies, A Bronx Tale, it is also known for all the amazing restaurants that can be found there. One such restaurant is Seafood City!
Seafood City on City Island, NY  ©2015 HollyDayz
Upon arrival to Seafood City you will notice a big parking lot. Depending on the time of year, that lot may be completely filled. No need to worry as there is another lot to handle the crowd. On days with amazing weather you will also see tons of bikers hanging out on their motorcycles.
Seafood City
Seafood City is not your typical restaurant. There is no host to seat you, no waiters coming to take your order, and no one coming to check and make sure everything is OK. Seafood City is a cafeteria style establishment. You get on a line, order your food, pay for it, and get a number. You find your own table. When your number is called you go and get your food.
If you are allergic or don’t care for seafood that is OK, there is an area to order pizza, burgers, fries, and more. There is another line you can jump on to order a drink. They also make great drinks that are not watered down by any means. The prices are good, especially for what you are ordering. Fried or boiled, it is your choice! Just remember they only take cash, but if you forget they do have an ATM.

Inside looking out  ©2015 HollyDayz
Inside looking out ©2015 HollyDayz

There is also an arcade area for the family to enjoy. A huge outdoor patio overlooking the water with another bar is located outside. It can get pretty packed during beautiful weather and weekends. Long lines, that move at a decent pace can be found. You will find all walks of life enjoying lunch or dinner.
Shrimp and Whiting  ©2015 HollyDayz
Shrimp and Whiting ©2015 HollyDayz

My favorite thing to order is the fried shrimp and whiting. It comes with fries, a pickle, cole slaw, and a lemon to squeeze. It is so good and very filling. Their shrimp is so good and well worth going for! The atmosphere is also enjoyable, watching the kids have fun and adults talking, listening to music, and enjoying themselves. If you ever get the opportunity, Seafood City on City Island is the place to go.
 ©2015 HollyDayz
©2015 HollyDayz

Have you ever been to City Island? If so, have you been to Seafood City? What is your favorite restaurant on City Island?

Previous Post
April 24, 2015
Next Post
April 24, 2015


  • Tyra

    Okay, this looks delicious! That shrimp and catfish, looks amazing. Will keep in mind for a quick eat when in NY.

    • Holly Dayz

      It is very good. Def a place to check out. The Bronx has gems too.

  • thesophislife

    Oh my! That food looks delicious!

    • Holly Dayz

      Very good food. I love that place.

  • Hector

    Can’t wait to go again thats are spot

    • Holly Dayz

      Me too! Love it there.

  • kp3reloaded

    I’ve never been to City Island, but it definitely looks like a fun place to visit. That seafood looks and sounds so good!

    • Holly Dayz

      It is a lot of fun. I really enjoy the atmosphere. Plus the food is yummy and affordable.

  • Stacie

    I never heard of City Island! I’m not a fan of seafood, but it sounds like you really enjoyed it!

    • Holly Dayz

      There are other places besides seafood on the island. Plus like I said if you don’t like seafood that is OK because they sell other things as well!

  • Kay's Ways (@OdashKay)

    OMG when I was pregnant I used to go there for the Shrimp & fries with fried lobster tails (yes together lol). The drinks are also out of this world, had many of good times at Seafood City, it’s the perfect local chill out spot for the Summer

    • Holly Dayz

      Nice, I need to try the fried lobster tails. Sounds good. I am glad you have gotten to experience it, I love that place.

Leave a Reply